National Key Lime Pie Day at The Waterfront Restaurant: A Sweet Slice of Florida History
Celebrate Friday, September 26th with Florida’s Favorite Dessert
This Friday, September 26th, 2025, is National Key Lime Pie Day, and there’s no better place to celebrate than The Waterfront Restaurant on Anna Maria Island. Nestled in the heart of paradise, The Waterfront not only serves up some of the best locally inspired dishes, but also proudly offers a Key Lime Pie so decadent, it deserves a holiday of its own.
The History of Key Lime Pie: A Florida Treasure
Few desserts can claim iconic status quite like Key Lime Pie. Born in the Florida Keys during the late 19th century, this tangy treat has roots as rich as its flavor. Early Floridians, without access to fresh milk or refrigeration, used canned sweetened condensed milk, egg yolks, and the juice of the native Key lime to craft a dessert that was both practical and delicious.
It wasn’t until the 1930s that the pie began to gain national attention, eventually becoming Florida’s official state pie in 2006. Authentic Key Lime Pie is known for its vibrant yellow filling, not green (a common misconception), and its crust can range from traditional graham cracker to buttery shortbread. The Waterfront’s version is a true-to-form celebration of this beloved dessert, honoring its heritage with every forkful.
For more on the pie’s fascinating history, check out Southern Living’s dive into Key Lime Pie origins.
So… What is National Key Lime Pie Day Anyway?
While the exact origin of National Key Lime Pie Day remains a mystery, it’s no surprise that this fan-favorite dessert has its own spotlight on the calendar. Falling perfectly into the tail-end of summer, September 26th is the ideal day to indulge in something citrusy, cold, and refreshing—especially in the warm Gulf Coast air.
Over the years, food holidays have become cultural celebrations, with foodies, bakers, chefs, and sweet-toothed fans across the country using social media to honor their favorite eats. For Florida locals, this particular holiday hits home. You’ll find specials, celebrations, and plenty of lime-zesting energy in kitchens across the state.
Key Lime Pie at The Waterfront: A Creamy Coastal Dream
The Key Lime Pie at The Waterfront Restaurant is a standout item on the dessert menu. What sets it apart? It’s all in the perfect balance of tart and sweet, the impossibly smooth texture, and the delicate whipped topping that doesn’t overpower the citrusy goodness of the lime. The buttery graham cracker crust crumbles with a satisfying crunch, complementing the creamy filling in each bite.
This isn’t just dessert—it’s an experience. Served with a view of the shimmering bay and a gentle ocean breeze, it’s no wonder this pie has become a fan favorite for locals and visitors alike.
Pairing Perfection: What to Sip with Your Slice
While Key Lime Pie is an all-star on its own, pairing it with the right drink elevates the experience. Luckily, The Waterfront Restaurant’s drink menu offers several amazing options to complement this Florida staple:
- Espresso Martini – The bold, bitter notes of espresso balance beautifully against the sweetness of the pie. View Espresso Martini
- Classic Mojito – Mint and lime are a match made in heaven. The mojito’s crisp, herbaceous profile pairs naturally with Key Lime Pie’s citrus zest. View Mojito
- Chardonnay – A slightly oaked Chardonnay with creamy mouthfeel and a touch of citrus brings the flavor full circle. Ask your server for the best selection.
- Prosecco – Bubbles + citrus = joy. A cold glass of bubbly Prosecco cuts through the richness of the pie and refreshes the palate.
Not sure what to pick? Ask one of The Waterfront’s expert servers for their perfect pairing recommendation. They’ll be happy to guide you!
Key Lime Pie’s Enduring Popularity
Once a humble fisherman’s dessert in the Keys, Key Lime Pie is now a national obsession—especially in Florida, where its roots run deep. It’s a staple in diners, fine-dining restaurants, food trucks, and bake-offs across the state. Its nostalgic charm, bright flavor, and simple ingredients make it an enduring favorite that spans generations.
Even food influencers and celebrity chefs have jumped aboard the Key Lime train. Shows on Food Network and Cooking Channel regularly feature pie-making contests, regional recipes, and even cocktail-inspired pie mashups. It’s no wonder #KeyLimePie trends every summer.
For more foodie fun, check out this Taste of Home guide to Key Lime Pie tips and tricks.
Why Celebrate at The Waterfront?
Whether it’s your first time visiting Anna Maria Island or your fiftieth, The Waterfront Restaurant offers a timeless setting for celebrating local flavors and national food holidays. Their commitment to quality, scratch-made dishes, and elevated dining with a casual vibe makes it the perfect place to mark National Key Lime Pie Day.
Here’s what guests love most:
- Stunning Waterfront Views – You can literally enjoy your pie steps away from the shore.
- Fresh, Scratch-Made Desserts – Every pie is crafted with love, using only the best ingredients.
- A Full Craft Cocktail Bar – Celebrate with a Key Lime Martini or a local beer alongside your dessert.
- Locally Inspired Menu – From fresh seafood to seasonal cocktails, everything here is Florida-forward.
Plan your visit now by viewing the full Waterfront menu and make sure to save room for dessert.
Make It a Key Lime Weekend
Why stop at Friday? Turn your dessert day into a weekend-long Key Lime celebration. Explore nearby shops, local beaches, and island attractions—then wind down at The Waterfront with a chilled cocktail and a creamy slice of pie.
Better yet, take a photo with your pie, post it with the hashtag #NationalKeyLimePieDay, and tag @thewaterfrontrestaurant for a chance to be featured on their social channels.
Final Thoughts: Pie, Paradise, and Pure Joy
Some holidays are just meant to be celebrated with a fork in hand and a smile on your face. National Key Lime Pie Day at The Waterfront Restaurant is exactly that—a delightful moment to savor the sunshine, the sea breeze, and one of Florida’s greatest culinary gifts.
So this Friday, whether you’re a local looking for a little sweet nostalgia or a visitor searching for the best pie in the state, you know where to go.
The Waterfront Restaurant
111 S Bay Blvd
Anna Maria, FL 34216
thewaterfrontrestaurant.net
